I really enjoy audiobooks. Over the last few years Iāve read more books using my ears than my eyes! But audiobooks are tricky critters.
An audiobook makes you pay attention to every word. Thereās no skimming long pastoral sections to get to the action. This can either make you appreciate hidden gems in these sections, or underline a writerās weakness. We do need description, world-building, and character backgrounds, but it takes skill to smoothly incorporate these into a narrative without bogging it down. Whenever I listen to Katherine Kerrās Deverry series, I find clever elements Iād overlooked in print.
Stories also have a rhythm to them. There are down or quiet moments in between the heart-hammering up scenes. Many writers are weaker in one of these tempos and audiobooks bring this out.
For example, while I wouldnāt say that Robert Jordan is necessarily weaker in one tempo, I did notice that The Eye of the Worldās rhythm matched The Lord of the Ringsā almost point for point. This was so distracting, I couldnāt enjoy the story.
These are just a couple of the reasons itās a good idea to record your completed draft and listen to it. What eludes you on the page will jump out at you on audio.
Once you have a polished tale, audiobooks can still play you false.
Professional editors will tell you itās better to just use āsaidā in dialogue, especially lengthy dialogue. They reason that itās easier on the reader because said fades into the background. But if youāre an audiobook reader, a lot of āsaidās in a short span is repetitive and grates on the ears. At least on my ears. š I vastly prefer writers with a more varied approach to dialogue.
The voice actor who reads your work is important as well. And authors generally have no say in the casting process unless theyāre reading themselves. For example, I recently listened to American Gods by Neil Gaiman on CD. A friend had recommended the TV show to me and I didnāt like it. I decided to see if the book was better (it definitely was!). Iām not sure I got the full impact of it, though. The readerās voice had this Lake Wobegone quality to it that sucked all the extremes out of the narrative. The result was rather ho-hum. And ho-hum is generally the last word people use for Neil Gaimanās writing.
Audiobook companies are also notorious for switching narrators in the middle of a series. Occasionally this is a good thing because the first reader was dreadful. Most of the time it gets the readers up in arms. Weāve grown accustomed to associating a certain voice with the series and its characters. Itās really jarring to change that and throws most readers right out of the story.
In a recent example, Lorelei King has read all of Patricia Briggsā Mercy Thompson series until the most recent addition, Silence Fallen. In Silence Fallen Lorelei King still reads the chapters from Mercyās point of view, but a male narrator now reads chapters from Adamās point of view. I didnāt like it, but had finally started to get used to it when, for example, the female narrator would pop in to the male section to let us know time was passing differently for each character. That was so jarring! I honestly donāt know why audiobook companies persist in doing this kind of thing.
To sum up, I think itās wise for writers to keep the audio version in mind. And maybe insist on casting control in your contract. š